Subscribe Now

Simply Enter Your Details To Find Out How
We Can Help Your Business


Ready to go on a Discovery?


To Book your Employee Metrics Lite session, please fill in the details below and we will be in contact.

Apply Now

Please fill up the fields below
Employee Matters Logo
Get in Touch Get in Touch (02) 8021 4206
  • HR Services
        • Outsourced HR
        • How We Work - HR
        • Employee Metrics - Data Diagnostics
        • Featured Industries:

        • Australian Startups
        • Finance, Insurance and FinTech
        • Featured Solutions:

        • HR Consulting
        • Workplace Training
        • HR Policies & Procedures
        • Employee Assistance Program (EAP)
        • Products and Packages

        • We deliver measurable results through great HR:

        • Hear What Our Clients Say
  • Recruitment Services
        • Outsourced Recruitment
        • Featured Solutions:

        • Tiered Recruitment Packages
        • Recruitment Partner Service (RPS)
        • Learn More:

        • Hiring Manager Training
        • Why Choose Us for Recruitment?
        • How We Work (RPS)

        • We’re not an agency, and our clients love that:

        • Hear What Our Clients Say
  • About Us
    • About Employee Matters
    • Meet the Team
    • What Our Clients Say
    • Referrals and Partnerships
    • Core Values and Vision
  • Resources
        • The Latest:

        • News and Media
        • Blog Articles
        • Videos and Webinars
        • Featured Content:

        • ER Legislation Resource Hub
        • e-Book: 7 ER Risks for Employers
        • Downloads and Knowledge Hub:

        • HR Forms & Checklists
        • 'Working From Home' Pack
        • HR & Recruitment FAQ’s
        • Book: "From Hire to Fire"
        • From the Archives:

        • 'Employees Matter' Podcast
  • Jobs
  • Contact Us

So you think contractors are the answer to your employee issues? – Think Again!

So you think contractors are the answer to your employee issues? – Think Again!
May 15, 2018
  • Written by Natasha Hawker
    Founder and Managing Director

    Natasha is a leading HR expert, entrepreneur, author and sought-after media commentator for outlets such as Sunrise (Channel 7), ABC Radio and The Australian Financial Review. Natasha co-founded Employee Matters in 2011 to help Australian businesses achieve success through their people.

I bet you used to think that using Independent Contractors was easy. Essentially, they needed to be working for you for no more than 80% of the time, have an ABN and invoice you for the work, and – bingo – you had an Independent Contractor.  No need to worry about PAYG, workers compensation or unfair dismissal rights. Unfortunately, it never really was that simple and, these days, it is more important than ever that you get this right.

With organisations increasingly looking to engage a flexible workforce, utilise the gig economy and get stuff done using Virtual Assistants and the like, it’s tempting to go down the independent contractor path. Be aware, however, that you’re potentially stepping into a minefield.

Did you know for instance that the ATO and Fair Work have their own tests for Independent Contractors? Whilst you might be meeting the obligations for the ATO, Fair Work could see it very differently. They have up to 10 ‘touch points’ that they look at to ascertain whether an independent contractor is actually an employee, and they’re not looking too favourably these days on organisations that don’t get it right.  Nor will these touch points give you a definitive answer as to whether your newly minted worker is the Independent Contractor you believe them to be, or really an employee in disguise.

The term used is ‘Sham Contracting’, and Fair Work are very happy to proceed with legal action against organisations who are deemed to be avoiding their legal obligations. This could result in fines for both the employer (up to $63K per breach) and its directors (up to $12,600 per breach), in addition to back pay of entitlements for workers and damages, etc.  It really can work out as an expensive exercise if you are wrong.

So how do you know?  

It comes down to assessing a few things about your agreement with the worker, like:

  • What does it look like from the paperwork (contracts, invoices, ABNs etc)?
  • What does it look like on the ground?
  • What is the level of control you have over the worker and the work done?

Some things to think about:

  • Do you control the hours that your Independent Contractors work and the specifics of how the work is done?
  • Are they wearing a uniform that has your company name on it and using your tools   and equipment?
  • Could they subcontract out the work to someone else if they wanted to?

These are just some of the things that Fair Work will consider when assessing whether you have a Sham Contracting arrangement in place.  

So if you are thinking about taking on Independent Contractors and want to minimise your risk, or you have Independent Contractors and want to check your arrangements, let us know. Our new Employment Status service may be just what you need.

Book a Free Call at a time to suit you, with one of our Employee Experts.

Tags: Management

Latest News and Media

Job Search 2026: The Power of Personality in the Age of AI

  • 11 February 2026
The job market has changed. If you’re applying for roles in 2026, you’re not just trying to impress a hiring manager, you’re trying to get past AI. Learn more in...
Read More

The Making of a CEO: Strategies for Success – Howse & Rivers

  • 12 September 2025
In a recent conversation with Adelle Howse from Howse & Rivers, Natasha Hawker shared the journey of starting and growing Employee Matters. While many see an "overnight success," the reality...
Read More

Building Stronger Businesses Through People: Natasha Hawker on the ScaleX Insider Podcast

  • 12 August 2025
“You don’t build a business — you build people and people build the business.” This was the central theme when Natasha Hawker, Founder of Employee Matters and leading expert in...
Read More

Experts Weigh In on Correct Hot-Desking Etiquette

  • 22 July 2025
Hot-desking is now common in many Australian workplaces, but not everyone knows the best way to share a desk. Natasha Hawker, managing director of HR and recruitment firm, Employee Matters,...
Read More

The Sick Tax: How to Tackle Presenteeism in Your Workplace

  • 3 June 2025
The Sick Tax in Australian Workplaces and Why ‘Presenteeism’ Is Costing Businesses Billions If you’ve ever felt guilty about calling in sick, you’re not alone. Natasha Hawker, founder of Employee...
Read More

High Paying Jobs You DON’T Need A Degree For

  • 20 May 2025
A university degree has long been seen as the primary path to a high salary, but with the evolving job market, many Australians are discovering alternative routes to rewarding careers....
Read More

Should You Speak Up if You See Bad Behaviour at Work?

  • 6 May 2025
Speaking Up at Work: What Should You Do When You Witness Unethical Behaviour? Workplace conflict is inevitable, but how it’s managed—or ignored—can make all the difference to employee wellbeing, team...
Read More

Tactic linking promotions to being in office completely divides Aussie workers

  • 27 April 2025
Promotions Now Tied to Office Attendance? The Return-to-Office Push Divides Aussie Workers A growing number of Australian employers are finding new ways to encourage staff back into the office —...
Read More

Latest Blog Articles

Why Every Business Needs a Clear Misconduct Policy

  • 26 February 2026
At Employee Matters, we spend a lot of time supporting businesses through difficult conversations. In many cases, those conversations start the same way: “We didn’t think we’d ever need a...
Read More

Personality is Your Superpower in the Age of AI

  • 24 February 2026
We are living in a new era of recruitment. With over 90% of Australian bosses now using Artificial Intelligence to advertise and hire, the landscape for job seekers has fundamentally...
Read More

How Outsourced HR Services Can Save You Time, Money and Stress

  • 24 February 2026
Most business owners don’t start a company because they’re passionate about employment contracts, performance plans, or award interpretations. Yet, before long, HR becomes a regular part of the working week....
Read More

Scrolling to Success: How to Recruit and Retain Generation Z

  • 16 February 2026
The Australian workforce is undergoing a seismic shift. As Baby Boomers retire and Millennials move into senior leadership, a new force has risen: Generation Z. Born between 1997 and 2012,...
Read More

How to Ask Exit Interview Questions That Actually Improve Your Workplace

  • 14 January 2026
When an employee leaves your business, it’s easy to focus on the logistics such as notice periods, handovers, and recruitment to fill the role. But every resignation is also an...
Read More

What Happens When an Employee Runs Out of Sick Leave?

  • 27 November 2025
Managing long or frequent employee absences can be complex. Once an employee has used all of their paid Personal/Carer’s Leave, your obligations shift - and so does your risk. Here’s...
Read More

The Employer’s Guide to the Work Christmas Party: Plan the Fun and Ditch the Risk

  • 19 November 2025
The end-of-year work Christmas party is an Australian tradition, a time to celebrate a year of hard work, build team morale and thank your employees for their efforts. But for...
Read More

Safety First, Spirits Second: How a Sydney Hospitality Group Became a Compliance Legend

  • 19 November 2025
The Sydney hospitality scene is buzzing, but behind the craft cocktails and boutique whiskeys, there's serious business - especially when it comes to compliance. Our client isn't just a stellar...
Read More

(02) 8021 4206
  • About Us
    • About Employee Matters
    • Book a Free Call
    • What Our Clients Say
  • Services
    • Outsourced HR Services
    • Outsourced Recruitment
    • Recruitment Partner Service (RPS)
  • Resources
    • News and Media
    • Forms & Checklists
    • Blog
  • News and Media
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

Employee Matters helps businesses in Sydney, Melbourne, Perth, Brisbane, and across all major Australian towns and cities with their HR and Recruitment needs.

Copyright | Employee Matters
Terms + Conditions | Privacy Policy
Design by Five by Five
Winning the War for Talent

Hiring is harder than ever. Finding great talent is the #1 challenge for business owners. Stop reactive hiring and start winning the war for talent with this practical 15-step recruitment guide.


Workplace and Management Training & Coaching Services

Our specialised training programs are meticulously crafted to meet the unique needs of your workforce, helping them excel in their roles so they can drive your success.


E-book: Winning the War for Talent

Enter your details below and start building a recruitment strategy that actually works — even in today’s challenging talent market


Are You Fully Across the New Employment Relation Changes?

Make compliance simple with our practical checklist outlining the essential implementation steps every employer must address:


Sample Exit Interview Template

Make your offboarding process smoother and more effective with our ready-to-use Exit Interview Template. Enter your details to download:


4 Steps to Managing Psychosocial Hazards and Risks

Protect your workplace from psychosocial risks. Access our 4-step guide by entering your details below:


Download Infographic: Workplace Sexual Harassment is Bad for Business

Workplace sexual harassment isn’t just a moral issue—it’s a costly business risk. Enter your details below to see the evidence behind its financial and organisational impact:


Working From Home Pack

The pack includes:

  • Comprehensive Employer Guide to Employees Working From Home
  • Comprehensive Employee Guide to Working From Home
  • Working From Home Policy
  • WH&S Working From Home Audit Checklist

Fill out the form below to access it.


Assess Your HR & Recruitment Practices

This self-assessment checklist helps you evaluate your current HR and recruitment practices and kickstart internal conversations about your future strategy. Fill out the form below to access it.


Psychosocial Hazards in the Workplace – The Facts You Need to Know

See why psychosocial hazards are among the fastest-growing challenges for employers. Enter your details below to access a snapshot of their rising financial and human impact in Australian workplaces.:


Get In Touch

Call us on (02) 8021 4206 or use the form below to tell us about your requirements and we’ll be in touch to guide you on which Employee Matters services are best for you:


Book a Free Call

We’re Here to Help!

Call us on 02 8021 4206 – email info@employeematters.com.au – or complete the form below to book a time that suits you:


HR Kickstart


What Matters

Subscribe to our newsletter ‘What Matters’ to stay up to date with all the latest news, useful downloadable assets and exclusive offers: